High-Definition video content is the wave of the future, right? The clarity offered by these new technologies simply blows standard definition TV out of the water.
So what’s wrong with HD? Why, I’m glad you asked!
#1) Closed Standards
If it wasn’t such a closed standard, the market might be more accepting. The level of DRM just doesn’t make it worth it for me. I have an early “HD Ready” TV which supports 720p, but doesn’t have HDMI or HDCP. “Sorry, you don’t get to play the movies you paid for at full quality.” All the technical capability is there, yet the companies have imposed a false limitation. Meanwhile, the pirates are taking their product, making it better, and giving it away for free. Now, I can totally understand the company expecting to receive compensation for their product, but with respect to their competition (legalities aside), they’re trying to charge more for an inferior product.
#2) Expensive and Unnecessary Hardware Upgrade Paths
My TV is hooked up to a Media Center PC that I built. If I wanted to move to HD, I’d need an input method–either Blu-Ray or an HD Tuner. Over-the-air HD is unencrypted and good for local channels, but that’s all the good news you get. Blu-Ray drives suffer from the aforementioned false restrictions, and to get HD Cable, you need what’s known as a CableCard. Want to buy a CableCard and put it in your current PC? Too bad. It’s “against regulations.” More false limitations. I think I could get a block of enriched Plutonium easier than a CableCard.
Now, even if I did have one or both of those things, to fully output my spankin’ HD signal, I’d need a new video card that has HDCP support (even though my current one is absolutely capable of handling HD-level video). I’d also have to get a new TV that has HDCP support (even though my current one still works okay). That’s about $1200 in unnecessary hardware. Does that make sense to you?
#3) Failure to promote upgrading existing collections
I believe the film studios should have set up an upgrade program, where you can send in your DVDs and get Blu-Ray versions of your movies for a modest upgrade fee. Being able to upgrade an existing movie collection easily and at minimal cost would help acceptance of a new format immensely.
